Dr. Gerald S. Hecht
Associate Professor of Psychology
College of Sciences
webmaster@psiwebsubr.org
I. WILHELM WUNDT’S FOUNDING OF THE SCIENCE OF PSYCHOLOGY: VOLUNTARISM
The name that Wundt gave to his approach to Psychology was voluntarism because
of its emphasis on will, choice, active synthesis and purpose (In a sense he
agreed with both Kant and Fechner).
Wundt's Voluntarism Consisted of Two Elements:
- Sensations:
result of a sensory organ (i.e., eye, ear) receiving stimulation from
the outside world and the resulting impulse in the nerves reaching the
brain. Sensations can vary in
- modality (visual, auditory, taste, etc.) and
- quality (within a modality i.e., red, blue, etc. for vision)
- Feelings:
emotional reactions that accompany sensations. All feelings exist as
points in a three dimensional space (tri-dimensional theory):
- pleasantness-unpleasantness
- excitement-calm
- strain-relaxation
- Wundt's Psychology was to be the study of how the mind actively,
purposefully and creatively combines or synthesizes these elements into
the rich and complex capabilities of the human mind.
- Example of Wundt's Methods: Introspective Mental Chronometry:
Measurement of the time needed by the mind to perform various
activities: Activities which take longer are more complex. The time
taken to perform a calculation (Calculation Time or CT) for example,
would be determined by first measuring:
- Simple Reaction Time or SRT (two numbers are presented visually
and the subject is instructed “push the button when you see two
numbers”)
- Calculation Reaction Time or CRT (two numbers are presented
visually and the subject is instructed “push the button when you
know the sum of the two numbers“)
- Canceling out the motor component (time it takes to push the button) by calculating: CRT-SRT= CT
- This would allow psychologists to quantify mental operations the same way that physiologists measure physical operations.
II. SUMMARY: WUNDT vs. FECHNER
Founded modern psychology through his activities as a promoter, advertiser, and
organizer of systematic experimentation of psychophysical phenomena. Established
the first psychological laboratory, edited the first psychological journal, and
granted the first academic degrees in psychology. Without Wundt’s
efforts--Psychology degrees would not exist.
Originated modern psychology-- was not trying to found a new science--his goal
was to understand the relationship between the mental and material worlds.
Without Fechner’s ideas-- Psychology would not have happened.
III. TITCHENER: THE MISREPRESENTATION OF WUNDT'S WORK: STRUCTURALISM
- Titchener: Summary of his “trashing of Wundt’s
work”: Only focused on the elements-- totally disregarded
Wundt’s larger scheme. Purported to be an “exact
copy” of Wundt-- but was not.
- Concentrated only on elements--left out creative synthesis
- Association was mechanical--not chemistry-like
- Disregarded Wundt's higher process (apperception) stuff e.g., reaction time for mental events, etc.
- Disregarded Wundt's tridimensional theory of feelings and only kept one of them: pleasantness – unpleasantness
IV. EDWARD BRADFORD TITCHENER--THIS IS YOUR LIFE
- Undergrad and Masters degrees at Oxford U -- Studied philosophy and the classics.
- Left England because colleagues were skeptical of scientific approach to psychological issues.
- Ph.D. with Wundt: 1892: Struck up a friendship an American
student--Frank Angell. Angell established one of the first American
Psychological laboratories at Cornell.
- Went to Cornell University in Ithaca NY as Angell's replacement when Angell went to Stanford.
- Quickly developed the largest doctoral program in psychology in the United States. "RULED HIS DOMAIN WITH AN IRON FIST"
- To Titchener, all Americans and Germans who claimed to be
psychologists were "...little more than watered-down Cartesians,
codified phrenologists, or worst of all, thinly disguised
theologists...."
- Established labs, researched, wrote (1893-1900).
- From 1900 onward:
- Told students what their research would be
- Used that research to produce his "system"
- "Bogus" translations of Wundt's books
- supportive (relatively speaking) of women in psychology graduate programs
- Margaret F. Washburn-- one of Titchener's students was the first
woman Ph.D. in Psychology… and the first woman elected to the
National Academy of Sciences.
V. TITCHENER’S STRUCTURALISM
- subject matter of psychology: conscious experience as that experience is dependent on the experiencing person(s).
- stimulus error problem
- immediate vs. mediate experience
- consciousness = the sum of our experiences s they exist in the moment
- mind = the sum of our experiences accumulated over a lifetime
- pure science
- only legitimate purpose: to discover the STRUCTURE of the mind.
- no applied aspects allowed in psychology
- subjects: only "normal" adult human beings…(whatever that
means) PERIOD...no animals, children or "defective minds" allowed.
- yes... again...this guy was a piece of work...here is a quote
from the man himself: "Science deals, not with values, but with facts.
There is no good or bad, sick or well, useful, or useless, in
science..."
- Introspection
- goal: analysis; to discover the "atoms of the mind"
- Total disregard of the essence of Wundt's methods: mental chronometry, etc.
- Elements of consciousness only please
- Defined three essential problems for Psychology (know them).
- Proposed three elementary states of consciousness (know them).
VI. CONTRIBUTIONS OF STRUCTURALISM
- Subject matter clearly defined ("my way or the highway")...
provided a strong, solid base against which younger, prettier and
smarter psychologists could rebel.
- In all fairness-- he was the first "feminist" in academia...backed both female faculty and grad students.
- However, he was also a fraud and a liar in many ways.... who
almost got away with completely obliterating the essence of the Wundt's
Psychology.
- Ironically, modern day cognitive psychology is very much like
Wundt's Psychological Science.... many generations (100+ years) have
elapsed between Wundt's original work and the recent "rediscovery" of
that work.